The Massachusetts murder cases of Brian Walshe and Karen Read have drawn renewed public attention, revealing a bizarre connection between the two through disgraced investigator Michael Proctor. Once a lead trooper in both cases, Proctor’s conduct has come under scrutiny following allegations of unprofessional behavior and offensive text messages.
Karen Read, accused of murdering her boyfriend John O’Keefe in 2022, faced a mistrial in 2024 after shocking revelations during cross-examination exposed Proctor’s derogatory texts. Proctor referred to Read as a “whackjob” and a “b***h,” even jokingly wishing her harm. His suspension without pay and pending disciplinary hearing have cast a shadow on his integrity.
Proctor also played a key role in the investigation of Ana Walshe’s disappearance in 2023. Ana, a mother of three, vanished on New Year’s Day, and her husband, Brian Walshe, faces accusations of her murder despite the absence of her body. Investigators allege that Brian dismembered her remains and disposed of them in trash bins. Suspicion about Proctor’s impartiality arose after defense attorneys flagged misconduct allegations against him, although prosecutors argue his texts didn’t impact the case.
As Brian’s trial looms, with jury selection set for October 2025, his defense has highlighted Proctor’s scandal, suggesting it could undermine the case. Meanwhile, prosecutors are focusing on DNA evidence, including a saw found in a dumpster and other materials from Brian’s home, to build their case.
The controversies surrounding Proctor have raised serious concerns about investigative integrity in high-profile cases. With both murder trials spotlighting his actions, the justice system faces mounting pressure to ensure impartiality and accountability.
